Review: Evergrey - The Storm Within (Album)

The Storm Within is, in many ways, a very typical Evergrey album and that's a great thing.

The very first notes, played by a steely-sounding piano, set the band's tone perfectly once more:

a hollowness which is soon enhanced by that certain feeling of dread and impending doom, delivered by the aggressively-tuned guitars.

With all elements already present since day one, Evergrey certainly have perfected their somewhat dark approach, but not without introducing clearer elements of release, the chorus of Distance being a great example. While there is potential for this mixture of heavy, repetitive pounding, and sometimes near lighthearted sounds to appear jarring - a reaction I had when listening to Fear off 2008's Torn for the first time, which features an opening that's as blistering as is it gets for Evergrey, yet soon breaks into an almost friendly chorus if it weren't for the wallowing bass-line.

At this point, however, this is far from being a mood breaker but rather an element capable of changing a song's mood and taking it to new places that still remain connected to the point of origin without necessarily relying on a strict formula on how to achieve this play of light and dark.

Even the most masterfully crafted musical darkness is bound to become stale once every one of its corners has been explored, which is why Evergrey neither give up on the familiar sound scape they have created in order to completely draw up the blinds and let light pour in, nor do they confine themselves into a single room and plunge it into absolute darkness.

Instead, they are adding rooms with various amounts of light coming through the windows to the existing structure, creating new shadows in the process. Some brightness is needed to create the various shades of grey, after all all, and despite adding new light sources, these shades of grey are far from gone.

It is interesting to see Evergrey branch out into collaborations as well. While the conservatively used female vocals of Carina Englund have always been a steady treat to listen to, this time around the band has also enlisted Floor Jansen, featured prominently on the track In Orbit, as well as - in surprising fashion - on the heavy-hitter Disconnect by showing off her operatic and choral abilities.

The return of what I assume to be Englund's daughter is something I enjoyed tremendously. Ever since her first appearance on Glorious Collision she's been featured on at least one track par album (I'm Drowning Alone, The Fire, Distance) and manages to accentuate these songs without becoming a gimmick.

Track review

Distance: A long-winded song that starts off slow and stirs up a phenomenal brooding atmosphere that's easy to mistake for monotone. While it is true that vast parts of the song feature repetition of simple elements - be they the various, very similar guitar riffs or the piano intro and outro - it needs to be noted that it's not just one riff that is being repeated throughout but a metamorphosis of sorts, rewarding keen and attentive listeners.

Secondly, the repetition serves as a specific counter-point to the almost hopeful chorus mentioned in the general review, allowing the listener to be drawn between two places that should be close to each other, but are miles apart just the same.

Passing Through is rather straight forward with a fair amount of energy it never quite loses - despite seemingly slowing down every now and then - a lot of which should be credited to the appealing keyboard work that leads the track in and out, as well as to the evolving instrumentation before the half-way point after which guitar solos take center stage and own most of the song's second half.

Someday: Where Distance starts off slow and brooding, Someday combines the dark atmosphere  with power even more quickly, only to launch into a further barrage and fly off to form a moody, trembling piece filled with urgency, of which it only tries to shed itself during the chorus and pre-chorus passage. Bringing in light and hopeful tones, however, only works out well during the pre-chorus, leaving the chorus itself in exquisite twilight.

The hymn-like guitar phrases strewn in throughout the song eventually turn it into an affair fitting for any rock arena and encourages every listener to raise their fist in unison.

Astray: Despite featuring a deceptively heavy start, Astray does not primarily rely on aggression and its underlying enemy to carry the song forward, and instead soon turns into a mixture of warm and chilling passages that are only occasionally broken up by these short, heavy parts sections.

Especially the chorus paints the song in a quite intimate, almost ballad-light light, presenting many sides back to back, forming a picture that keeps surprising with its many layers even after multiple listens.

The Impossible quickly became one of my favorites off The Storm Within, greatly drawing its appeal from the simple, yet captivating song structure. There’s a piano, there’s Englund’s pained voice, a keyboard mainly for setting the mood, as well as strings to further add to the somber mood. The tension they build up together is never quite released and does not break into a furious sonic storm towards the end.

My Allied Ocean, however, picks up the thread straight away and may just feature the heaviest opening sequence on this album. Even Englund starts into a rather aggressive first verse and helps the song blast away.

The chorus is, once more, crashing different moods into each other, suddenly transitioning from pure aggression to what sounds like hope incarnate – to the point where the lyrical passage of “want this world to burn” is accompanied by bright-sounding keyboard notes. At the same time, however, the song does not even bother slowing down and simply powers through the chorus like before, thus adding to the musical ambivalence without losing its direction or energy.

Much to my delight, there’s a spoken word section sampled from Englund’s voice woven into the song’s second half right, right before the almost obligatory solo section. The instruments even plow straight through this section, allowing no breather until the song’s very end.

In Orbit: A mostly mid-tempo song heavily accentuated by a sweeping and choir-like keyboard in the background. While it is not exactly pretending to be a ballad, heavy guitars do not dominate the song either, creating a heavy mellowness.
Englund holds the reigns for the first verse and chorus before Floor Jansen takes over verse two, turning the next iteration of the chorus into a duet. At times it even sounds like her voice is mixed into the keyboard choir I mentioned before – it may just very well be her voice all by herself! A delightful mix at any rate.

After the song takes the typical Evergrey tangent with solos and instrumental passages, a final extended chorus duet even has Jansen practically pushing Englund into the vocal background, going as far as sending the song off by herself and seemingly entering into a little duet with the guitars. She certainly shows off her voice in this track, making it another album highlight.

The Lonely Monarch has the questionable honor of being seemingly out of place on this album. Not because it sounds wildly different and fails in its experiments, but rather because its strengths can be boiled down to more of the same, albeit on a high level. Maybe it’d have a better spotlight on a different position on the album, but considering that the song itself is an instance where the Evergrey formula of making songs clearly shines through, on an album with many songs that rarely break said formula, there may simply not be a perfect place for a song that hardly stands out.

That said, there is nothing particularly wrong with The Lonely Monarch. Englund’s voice does sound refreshingly weary and soft, and yet manages to launch into a more demanding voice later on with ease.

A part that does stand out, however, is the section briefly slowing the song down between solos and final chorus iteration, calling back to older songs and itself at the same time.

Being placed between the first feature of Floor Jansen – despite this song being mostly on-formula as well – and the extra-ordinary follow up The Paradox Of The Flame featuring Carina Englund, as well as Disconnect, which features Jansen yet again, The Lonely Monarch simply cannot keep up. It may have been more favorable for this song to stay clear of this triad, possibly by switching places with In Orbit.

The Paradox Of The Flame - a tragic ballad that strongly relies on strings, especially the violin to play the singing couple of Tom and Carina Englund off each other - doesn’t shy away from heavier guitar sounds towards the end, while never quite gaining momentum. Instead the song elects to preserve the mood, even direct it into a cue from Recreation Day, before finally a violin-piano duet carries the song off to slowly fade out. A simply fantastic song.

Disconnect is another left hook resembling My Allied Ocean following The Impossible’s stored anticipation, albeit the change of mood being vastly different. As the album’s longest song at seven minutes, it surprises with featuring Floor Jansen again – however she is not contributing clean vocals this time around, but lends her voice in an almost operatic fashion to the chorus, this time clearly leading the simulated choir in the background and steadily singing her way into the foreground with each instance. There’s also yet another treat buried here, a not-so-subtle callback to various older songs like Madness Caught Another Victim, To Fit The Mold, and The Aftermath, rolled into one passage. It may even be a direct phrase from a song I can’t seize, but either way it kind of makes you expect Englund to burst into “It’s December...” from The Aftermath. Well done!

The Storm Within closes the album and continues where Disconnect left off while sadly replacing the Jansen-choir voices with a keyboard-simulated one again. Calm and angelic at first, the song picks up a little steam after about one and a half minutes. It stands out by foregoing the typical grey atmosphere and sounding almost entirely upbeat, with only a few dreary piano notes here and there. A sign of hope at the end of a rollercoaster ride through light and shadows, uneventful yet serene, and never boring, despite seemingly meandering onwards. This only gives the song a river-like quality, suggesting to close one’s eyes and let it sink in with all the other things on this album. Englund already stated on promotional interviews preceding the album’s release that The Storm Within is an album that takes time to process and fully take in, and this song, aptly sharing the title, is the embodiment of this very notion.

Conclusion

Where Hymns For The Broken was a little light on the band’s staple in-your-face song openings, it picks up the slack, but does not indulge in it too much, and where Monday Morning Apocalypse and Torn featured more concise and heaviness-focused tracks, it presents a wide range of songs and passages, retracing some old paths as well as opening up new ones. While it not exactly an explicit anniversary record, there certainly are number of callbacks to the past, celebrating it in its own way while giving a glimpse of what may be to come.

As a whole it may not be Evergrey’s strongest album, but after 20 years this hardly matters since there are no filler songs, no evident let-downs, or failed experiments. It’s entertaining all the way through – barring The Lonely Monarch’s placement, which is only a minor hiccup at most – and is far from a “listen to it once and be done” affair.

It’s Evergrey in all its essence. My only wish is for the band to break the heavy / dark opening / verse – light / positive chorus pattern more often and more obviously these days, but that’s simply a personal preference.

There are official videos out on Youtube for:
Distance
Passing Through
The Paradox Of The Flame

Give them a listen and enjoy!